Skip to main content
Manchester United fans protest against the club owners ahead of the Premier League match between Manchester United and Fulham at Old Trafford, Manchester, UK on 1 February 2026.
The tragedy of Manchester United Pro Sports Images

Et tu Brute? The Shakespearean tragedy of the modern Manchester United

Michael Carrick was not Julius Caesar. But as it transpired, that’s sort of the point. He probably had more in common with Puyi, while the role of Manchester United head coach in and of itself represented Caesar.

13.11.26, 16:44 7 Minute Read

Michael Carrick was not Julius Caesar. But as it transpired, that’s sort of the point. He probably had more in common with Puyi, while the role of Manchester United head coach  in and of itself represented Caesar.  

However, the role of Brutus fits perfectly for Jason Wilcox and Omar Berrada, whose overdue sacking of Carrick on Thursday after a difficult week for the Old Trafford club was one final act of betrayal and, as far as United supporters are concerned, one final act of self-preservation that they are permitted to execute while employed by the club.  

Carrick was the man whose contribution as coach covered up the lack of a plan by carrying the club to the Champions League against all reasonable expectations last season. He was the man who didn’t publicly complain even though he was given a squad that was ill-equipped to deal with the season in front of him. He was the man who insisted he was happy with the squad; who insisted there were fine margins between his side succeeding and failing as the form dropped off a cliff; who protected his players by recalling them into the team after most strong clubs would have been much harsher; who listened to the vitriolic anger flood down the stands towards the directors and still acted as an umbrella, facing the press, never once allowing the club to become submerged by controversy.

Become a member today.

The 1878 needs its community to support independent, high-quality coverage of Manchester United. Subscribe to a monthly or annual package today to be a part of something special.

Subscribe for £5

Already have an account? Sign in

Wayne Barton

Wayne Barton

Chief Manchester United Correspondent

Get started with our free newsletter

Sign up to receive your free newsletter with articles and analysis from our team

By entering your email address you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and consent to receive emails from The 1878.