Skip to main content
Erling Haaland (9) of Manchester City runs to celebrate scoring to make it 0-1 after referee Michael Oliver points to the spot after a VAR review during the Premier League match between Manchester United and Manchester City at Old Trafford, Manchester, UK on 13 September 2026.
Goal give, Michael Oliver signals for Erling Haaland's goal Pro Sport Images

Manchester United deserve more than another apology after derby VAR controversy

An apology arrived within hours of the final whistle, but it could not change the result. WAYNE BARTON examines the controversy surrounding Manchester City’s derby winner and why Manchester United have every right to feel aggrieved.

14.09.26, 17:04 Updated 14.09.26, 17:21 3 Minute Read

Wayne Barton

Wayne Barton

‘That’ll be great, that,’ Michael Carrick said in his post-match press conference after the Manchester derby when asked if he anticipated an apology from Pro Ref following the controversy around Erling Haaland’s winning goal. ‘Yeah, I can’t wait for that.’

Haaland put the ball in the net just before the hour mark at Old Trafford, but, in acknowledging his team-mate Enzo Fernández was offside, coyly accepted the flag of the referee’s assistant that disallowed it. The Norwegian is a world-class finisher, and a modern striker at that, and knows to act first and deal with the consequences later.

Become a member today.

The 1878 needs its community to support independent, high-quality coverage of Manchester United. Subscribe to a monthly or annual package today to be a part of something special.

Subscribe for £5

Already have an account? Sign in

Wayne Barton

Wayne Barton Editor

Get started with our free newsletter

Sign up to receive your free newsletter with articles and analysis from our team

By entering your email address you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and consent to receive emails from The 1878.